Homelab · Networking
This post contains an affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
I made a switch that, at first, I didn't think was necessary.
For several months, I had been running my own custom Wi-Fi setup using three different access points. It worked, and in many ways, I liked having that level of control. But over time, I started running into problems that became increasingly difficult to ignore.
The biggest issue was how certain devices handled the split between my 2.4 GHz and 5 GHz networks. I also had one access point that caused a broadcast storm, a problem so severe that it could bring down the entire network.
That was the point where I started reconsidering my setup.
While I was figuring out what to do, I temporarily replaced the problematic access point in my office with a simple TP-Link range extender plugged directly into a wall outlet. It wasn't an elegant solution, but it kept things working while I waited for the replacement.
Eventually, I decided to go with something specifically designed to handle this problem: a TP-Link Deco X15 (AX1500) mesh system, with all three units wired back to the network over Ethernet.
And it works extremely well.
The setup
Wi-Fi: TP-Link Deco X15 (AX1500), 3 units, Access Point mode, wired backhaul
Firewall / DHCP: OPNsense
DNS filtering: Pi-hole
Coverage: roughly 1,200 m², fully cabled property
Less control, more intelligence
The biggest difference is that I gave up some of the independence I had with my previous setup.
Previously, I could separate devices based on the network they connected to. I had a 2.4 GHz network and a 5 GHz network, each with its own name, and I decided which devices belonged to each one. Some devices connected exclusively to 5 GHz, while others were limited to 2.4 GHz.
The Deco system takes a different approach.
Instead of exposing those bands as separate networks, it makes that decision for you. Every device connects to the same network name, and the system determines which band makes the most sense based on the device and what it currently needs.
Normally, I'm not a huge fan of giving up that kind of control.
But in this case, it works.
Across my roughly 1,200-square-meter property, I have essentially the same coverage and availability I had before. My services continue to work on the devices that need them. What I no longer have is the ability to split devices across separate Wi-Fi networks.
That's the biggest compromise I've made.
And surprisingly, it's not a dealbreaker.
The setup was almost too easy
The actual installation was incredibly simple, with one catch.
I placed the units, wired them in, switched the system to Access Point mode, and used the same network name and password as my old main network.
One network name, all three units on Ethernet backhaul. The app also flagged my next bottleneck: an old 100 Mbps switch.
Most of my devices simply reconnected.
The exceptions were the few devices set to use my old 5 GHz-only network, which no longer existed. One of them was my headless media server: a laptop with a cracked screen that I manage over SSH. When its network disappeared, it went offline, and I had no screen to fix it from. I ended up connecting a monitor and keyboard, and while I was at it, I moved it to a permanent wired connection through a USB Ethernet adapter.
Lesson learned — anything headless should never depend on Wi-Fi.
There was a second, sneakier side effect. Modern phones use a randomized MAC address for each Wi-Fi network they join. When the network changed, some phones showed up as brand-new devices and quietly slipped out of the IP reservations and Pi-hole filtering groups I had set up for them.
Heads up — if you rely on MAC-based rules, check them after any Wi-Fi change.
After that?
Everything just worked.
And that's the part I appreciate the most.
What I lost
The downside is that I lost some flexibility.
With my previous setup, I could decide exactly which network each device joined. The Deco system isn't really designed around that philosophy. It's built to make the network work automatically.
It also comes with a catch I didn't love: there's no web-based setup. Configuration has to be done through TP-Link's mobile app, and that requires a TP-Link account. For someone who prefers self-hosted, local-only tools, that's a real drawback.
For someone who wants maximum control over their Wi-Fi, these might be significant disadvantages.
For me, the tradeoff is reasonable, mostly because of how I set it up.
Where the control actually lives
I'm running the Deco system in Access Point mode, behind my OPNsense firewall and Pi-hole.
That means the Deco only does one job: Wi-Fi. It doesn't hand out IP addresses, it doesn't filter anything, and it doesn't make routing decisions. My firewall still assigns every address, my DHCP reservations still apply, and Pi-hole still filters DNS for every device on the network.
The control I gave up is control over the radios, not over the network itself.
And I still have a plan for segmentation
I'm not completely giving up on network separation, either.
One limitation I ran into is that the Deco, in Access Point mode, can't tag separate Wi-Fi networks onto separate VLANs. So true isolation has to happen somewhere else.
My plan is to repurpose one of my older access points as a completely separate guest network, connected to its own port on the firewall. Visitors get internet access and nothing else.
My security cameras are wired, so they don't need a separate access point at all. They'll stay on the main network, but the firewall will block them from reaching the internet.
Smart TVs and similar devices get a different treatment: Pi-hole blocks their telemetry, and the firewall forces all their DNS traffic through it, so devices with hardcoded DNS servers can't sneak around it.
That gives me an interesting combination: the Deco system handles the household Wi-Fi, while the firewall and an older access point handle everything that needs to stay apart.
What it cost
One more thing worth saying: this upgrade didn't break the bank.
~$130
Total spent · Deco X15 three-pack
The only thing I bought was the Deco X15 three-pack, for about $130. Everything else, from the firewall and Pi-hole to the cabling and the older access points, was infrastructure I already had.
For the stability I got in return, it's one of the best-value changes I've made to my network.
Affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
So, was the switch worth it?
Absolutely.
I went from a setup that gave me more control but occasionally created problems, to one that gives me slightly less control but is considerably more stable and smarter about how it manages Wi-Fi.
And sometimes, that's the better choice.
I've spent a lot of time building systems where I control every little detail. But there's also something to be said for installing something, turning it on, and having it simply do its job.
In this case, I'm willing to give up a little independence in exchange for a network I don't have to constantly think about.
And that might be the biggest upgrade of all.






